This list ranks the number of times publications have had stories selected by the Best American Mystery Stories Anthology from 2009-2010.
| Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine | 5 |
| Blue Religion | 2 |
| Boston Noir | 2 |
| Las Vegas Noir | 2 |
| The Prosecution Rests | 2 |
| Thuglit | 2 |
| Alaska Quarterly Review | 1 |
| Alfred Hitchcock Mystery Magazine | 1 |
| At The Scene of the Crime | 1 |
| Black Noir | 1 |
| Hayden’s Ferry Review | 1 |
| Murder Past, Murder Present | 1 |
| One Story | 1 |
| Oregon Literary Review | 1 |
| Shenandoah | 1 |
| Sherlock Holmes in America | 1 |
| The Gettysburg Review | 1 |
| The Literary Review | 1 |
| Thriller 1 | 1 |
| Thriller 2 | 1 |
| Virginia Quarterly Review | 1 |
| The Kenyon Review | 1 |
| robkantner.com | 1 |
| The New Yorker | 1 |
| Conjunctions | 1 |
| The Oxford American | 1 |
| Red Wheelbarrows | 1 |
| Loch Raven Review | 1 |
| Sideways in Crimes | 1 |
| The Yale Review | 1 |
The Rankings 